Choosing between silicone and rubber is the first engineering decision in any custom parts project — and the most common mistake is choosing by price alone. Two parts that look identical in a catalog can differ five-fold in unit cost and by more than 200°C in service ceiling, and that one callout decides whether the program runs quietly or returns from the field.
This guide walks through the five variables that actually decide the answer — temperature, chemical exposure, compliance, hardness and unit cost — and closes with a selection checklist you can run before you request a quote.
Temperature Range: The First Filter
Silicone works from -70°C to 232°C and keeps elasticity at both extremes. The range is not a marketing figure: it comes from the Si-O backbone, which stays flexible where carbon-chain rubbers stiffen. A silicone gasket still seals in a cold-chain cabinet at -40°C, and a silicone pad survives a 200°C environment that would embrittle NBR.
The rubber families are narrower, and each has its own ceiling: NBR tops out near 120°C; EPDM reaches 150°C; FKM handles 250°C but costs several times more. Below its ceiling, however, each family fights back with better tensile strength, tear strength and abrasion resistance than silicone. The correct reading is not "silicone is better" but "silicone is wider".
The most common mistake here is specifying silicone for an oil-contact application running at 60°C because silicone sounds premium. Silicone swells in mineral oil and loses dimensional stability, so NBR would have cost less and lasted longer. Temperature alone is never the whole answer — it is only the first filter.
Chemical Resistance: Ask What Actually Touches the Part
For mineral oils and fuels, NBR and FKM are the right answers — silicone swells in oil. For water, steam, ozone and UV, EPDM and silicone lead. For weak acids and alkalis, both silicone and EPDM perform well.
Three questions turn that table into a decision: what is the fluid (exact name, viscosity and additive package — "oil" is not a specification), at what concentration, and for how long? A splash of hydraulic fluid during maintenance is a different requirement from permanent immersion. Ask about cleaning agents too: CIP caustics and alcohol wipes are two of the most frequent causes of unexpected swelling in food and medical equipment.
A practical exposure checklist: list every medium the part meets, including cleaners and lubricants; mark continuous versus intermittent contact; record the service temperature of each medium; note whether the medium is a mixture, because fuels and cutting fluids usually are; and request an immersion test on the two candidate compounds before tooling is cut.
Compliance: Food Contact, Medical and Automotive
Food-contact (FDA 21 CFR 177.2600, LFGB) and medical (USP Class VI, ISO 10993) applications usually force silicone; automotive and industrial parts rarely need it. The reason is chemistry: platinum-cured silicone leaves no peroxide by-products and accepts food-grade filler systems, so the same polymer family covers both a coffee-machine seal and a wearable pad.
RoHS and REACH are a documentation exercise rather than a material choice, because silicone and most rubber families are available compliant. Request the declaration against the exact compound code — the declaration follows the formula, not the polymer family, so a generic "silicone is REACH compliant" statement is worth nothing at an audit.
One distinction buyers miss: a compound certificate (FDA or LFGB for the material) and a factory quality certificate (ISO 9001, ISO 14001, IATF 16949) are different documents answering different questions. Ask for both. Rubbrother supplies food-contact grades to FDA and LFGB on request and runs an ISO 9001 / ISO 14001 / IATF 16949 quality system behind them.
Cost and Hardness: The Two Variables You Tune Last
NBR and EPDM are the economical workhorses; silicone sits mid-range; FKM is premium. Cost is driven by the polymer, the filler system and the cure system, which is why two compounds of the same polymer can differ noticeably in price — a food-contact or low-compression-set grade always costs more than a general-purpose grade.
Hardness is largely independent of the material family: most of these compounds are available across roughly Shore A 30-80, and changing hardness alters stiffness and sealing force far more than it alters chemical resistance. Buyers often try to fix a leaking seal by moving to a harder compound when the real fix is gland geometry, compression ratio or surface finish.
A Selection Checklist You Can Run Before the RFQ
Write these seven items down before contacting a supplier: continuous and peak service temperature; every contacting medium including cleaners; indoor or outdoor exposure with UV and ozone; required compliance documents; target hardness with a tolerance band; annual volume and expected batch size; and assembly compression ratio.
Send that list with a 2D drawing carrying tolerances or a 3D STEP file, and a manufacturer can shortlist compounds in one pass instead of three rounds of email. The right approach is to let the environment — not the catalog — pick the material, then optimize grade and hardness within it.
That is how Rubbrother quotes: send us your operating conditions and we will propose 2-3 compound options with their cost implications. Quotations are returned within 24 hours, new-mold quotations within 7 days, and samples ship in 7-12 working days depending on mold complexity. Mold and sampling fees are refunded once the bulk order reaches the agreed volume, MOQ is flexible, and sample freight is paid by the buyer. If you would rather verify the factory first, third-party audits and video factory tours are welcome.
Both materials are molded on the same presses — see how they perform in one part family in our custom rubber and silicone bellows range.
